This is an old revision of the document!
Psychology/Survival Strategies/Maladapted
People Pleasing
People pleasing is the practice of exceedingly analyzing and conforming to another person's attitude with the primary goal of minimizing friction, to avoid punishment, rejection or abandonment. This is typically a learned strategy employed, for example, by children seeking to appease emotionally volatile caregivers. Other factors include conditional affection, social rejection, bullying, cultural expectations, or repeated experiences of being rewarded for self-sacrifice. In response, people pleasers developed strong appeasement strategies like constant, nearly ritualized apologization, avoiding doing anything that could even theoretically upset someone and constantly asking for permission for even the most mundane things. They might also routinely ask for reassurance and are very averse to doing things they aren't good at/might fail at, out of fear of being criticized, or emotionally or physically punished for it. Because of this, they might have strongly internalized “toxic perfectionism”. Depending on their past, people pleasers can be highly preoccupied with decorum, sitting upright like a plank at the dinner table, walking stiffly and in general being very precise and needlessly efficient with how they move about.
While people pleasing is a necessary survival strategy for affected children, it becomes problematic later in life or already earlier with other people. Apart from the fact that people pleasers neglect their own needs, people pleasing itself is highly stressful and adds a lot of cognitive load for day-to-day activities. This cognitive load penalty is stress, makes everything for them harder. It also compounds pre-existing conditions like depression, making it even harder for them to attend to and complete tasks. Preoccupation with the needs and desires of others prevents people pleasers from self-expression, which makes it impossible for others to form a genuine bond/relationship with them (requires self-expression, otherwise you're just making friends with yourself). For others, people pleasing is problematic because people pleasing antics have a tendency of getting in the way and, potentially, becoming a nuisance. Most people don't constantly need to be apologized to and, while they probably accept apologies out of politeness, they'd probably prefer doing things with people pleasers without constantly taking time out of what they're doing to re-affirm to them that there still is no need to freak out. Similarly, people pleasers tend to leave planning for things to the people around them (so that they plan the way they like it) which can be problematic if a shared activity is meant to accommodate the desires of both sides. People pleasers frequently need to be pushed/forced to express their desires, which can feel to others as though they are not pulling their weight or even don't care about the shared activity to begin with.
Outside of therapy, the strategy to counteract people pleasing is making positive experiences with better survival strategies. People pleasers need to be shown that they can live a better life with other, more nuanced strategies and that they will not be struck down for expressing even the slightest hint of having a personality. However, this also requires a generous amount of insight, as people pleasers generally do not tend to believe that not expressing their own wishes is a problem that they need to work on. The problem is that pushing people pleasers into forming opinions every once in a while works because, by pushing them, you are essentially saying that you will be more pleased if they form an opinion right now. However, this has no long-term benefit. People pleasers need to undergo a fundamental shift in their relationship to themselves (ie. their personality, their needs, their desires and many other things which, so far, they have all but suppressed and continue to keep suppressed).
As someone in direct contact with people pleasers, it is important not to emulate/mirror the behaviors that led to the formation of people pleasing strategies to begin with. While they might be exceedingly polite, maybe even to the point of being nuisant, expressing frustration over these behaviors only reinforces the exact structures that make them behave this way. Their feelings, especially the fears that fuel their maladapted behavior, must be recognized, understood and validated. Improvement is brought about by effort on both sides: The people in direct contact with a people pleaser must be tolerant of their antics and be compassionate. The people pleaser must acknowledge that they have an issue and actively work to fix it. In many cases, this involves the analysis of and treatment of underlying conditions, often trauma-related, which may express in mood disorders (among others).
Personally, I generally count the antics of people pleasing against the individual. I do not treat them worse and I definitely do not act to make their situation worse, but I try to emulate a healthy level of boundary-setting by letting them know that their excessive level of politeness is, in fact, unsolicited. The idea is that by setting a boundary that is 1) healthy and 2) obvious to see, it can lead to learning on the people pleaser's part as they observe healthy boundaries being set without causing drama. This, ideally, inspires copying, at which point the person will make their first experiences of setting their own healthy boundaries and, thusly, taking care of their own needs. This in turn ideally leads to positive experiences, and this should set off a chain reaction in which positive experiences with taking care of oneself and exhibiting self-expression continually make it easier for the affected person to continue doing that.
